Skip to main content

Gender diversity in management and corporate financial performance: A systematic literature review

Written by: Luiz Eduardo Gaio, Angela Christina Lucas, Johan Hendrik Poker Junior, Marcio Marcelo Belli
Published on: Jun 2, 2025

Corporate gender divide
Photo Credit: Shutterstock / FGC

Abstract

With many studies on the participation of women in management positions, a systematic review of gender diversity and its impact on the financial performance of companies over the last 20 years is in demand. To this end, we conducted a literature review of 370 articles, 359 of which were empirical studies published in the most relevant journals of Finance and Business Administration. As a result of the analysis, the characteristics of the research, the main authors, the journals, the theories used, and the relationships between variables were identified. The results show that most research points to evidence of a positive relationship between female participation and financial performance under different aspects (e.g., return, risk, cost of capital, fraud, etc.). This study contributes to the academic debate on the relationship between gender diversity and firm performance. In addition to this review, we outline a theoretical framework and present future research agendas.

1 INTRODUCTION

Gender diversity is an increasingly relevant topic in business. The literature shows that companies that value diversity in their staff tend to present better financial results (Sattar et al., 2023), risk reduction (Guizani & Abdalkrim, 2023), lower cost of capital (Aljughaiman et al., 2022), higher productivity (Frink et al., 2003), lower debt (Muhammad et al., 2022), the better quality of accounting information (Anh & Khuong, 2022), and even lower rates of accounting fraud (Wang et al. 2022). In this sense, the implementation of diversity policies in management positions and the adoption of quotas in developed countries (Eckbo et al., 2022; Ferrari et al., 2021) are some of the strategies adopted to promote gender equality in the workplace, aligning with Goal 5 of the UN Agenda 2030 (UN, 2023).

Currently, many countries worldwide have implemented quotas to increase women's representation on company boards. Norway pioneered this agenda (Comi et al., 2020). These quotas ensure that women have a stronger voice in decision-making in large companies (Eckbo et al., 2022) and are part of a Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) strategy. Boukattaya et al. (2022) state that CSR is one of the company's main strategies, mainly due to the mandatory participation of women on company boards. Countries that have implemented quotas include Norway, France, Spain, and India (Comi et al., 2020). While there are debates about the effectiveness and necessity of these quotas, many argue that they are important for ensuring gender equality in the workplace and in wider society (Eckbo et al., 2022). As more countries recognize the importance of gender diversity on boards of directors, it is possible that more quotas will be implemented around the world, and society will seek more inclusive actions.

Aiming to assess the impact of greater female participation in management positions, research on gender has evolved over the years, and existing literature reviews allow a critical analysis of theoretical and empirical contributions on the subject. Shore et al. (2009) made an important review of studies on diversity in the workforce by different dimensions (e.g., age, race, gender, sexual orientation, disability, and culture). This study contributes to diversity in its broad concept, as it develops an integrative model. Bell et al. (2011) reviewed studies of demographic diversity and its relationship with team performance. Unlike Shore et al. (2009), who performed a descriptive analysis of the literature, Bell et al. (2011) performed a meta-analysis, and Van Dijk et al. (2012) investigated demographic diversity and performance through a meta-analysis. Focusing on diversity in the board of directors of companies, Baker et al. (2020) carried out an extensive bibliometric study and Knyazeva et al. (2021) conducted a systematic review. The findings of Baker et al. (2020) were essential for identifying the main authors participating in this academic debate. Khatib et al. (2021) and Bhatia and Gulati (2021) also reviewed the literature on board diversity but focused on financial institutions. Focusing on gender diversity, Girardone et al. (2021) reviewed the literature on the role of women on the board and its relationship with Corporate Social Responsibility and corporate governance. Halliday et al. (2021) also focus on gender diversity. In addition, Yu and Madison (2021) systematically review the impact of gender quotas on financial performance.

While the literature on diversity is extensive, there is still a limited number of studies that have addressed the issue of gender diversity and corporate financial performance (Yu & Madison, 2021; Herrera-Cano & Gonzalez-Perez, 2019, Yu & Madison, 2021, Hazaea et al., 2023, Laique et. al, 2023). Additionally, we note that some studies analyze corporate performance perspective in a broader context, including financial variables (Wagana and Nzulwa 2016, Nguyễn & Muniandy, 2020, Gupta et al. 2023, Hussain et al., 2024). However, in all cases, the participation of women in the Board of Directors was explored. The only review that addresses gender diversity in various management positions (Ciappei et al., 2023) does not delve into financial performance as a central theme. This does not allow us to understand whether women in Top Management Teams have positive financial performance results. We also note that in some cases, although well-analyzed, the reviews use a small sample size, which to some extent does not represent the volume of articles existing on the subject (Wagana and Nzulwa, 2016, Yu & Madison, 2021, Hussain et al. 2024, Gupta et al. 2023, Hazaea et al. 2023, Laique et al. 2023). Additionally, we noticed that some reviews are bibliometric in nature, focusing on aspects of citation networks, number of articles, journals, and impacts (Laique et al., 2023; Hussain et al. 2024), which weakens the idea of conducting a broader analysis of the implications and results of the inclusion of women in management positions. Thus, the limited number of studies investigated, the bibliometric method employed, and the absence of studies that analyze the position of women in other high-ranking positions besides the board does not allow for a comprehensive understanding of the relationships among women in different positions and corporate outcomes.

This study explores the relationship between gender diversity and corporate financial performance, seeking to understand the following points: (i) whether there is heterogeneity in this relationship according to geographical considerations, given that legal aspects regarding quota policies and incentives from countries pursuing sustainability agendas may influence performance; (ii) whether there is a difference in performance based on the positions in which women have increased participation; (iii) whether firm performance depends on the financial metric used to measure it; and (iv) whether financial results differ depending on the method of measuring gender diversity. Additionally, we aim to investigate the main journals, types of research, databases, methods, and theoretical discussions.

Considering the importance of gender diversity in the business world and its relationship with gender inequalities, it is essential to understand practices and policies that can promote a more inclusive and diverse work environment. This study contributes to the debate on the subject by critically analyzing the existing evidence and discussing its implications for business management.

After examining the literature on the relationship between gender diversity and firms' financial performance, we describe a conceptual and theoretical framework to guide our research. To guide our investigation, we set out some research questions: What is the geographic and temporal distribution of research on gender diversity? What are the most frequently used data analysis methods and techniques in this field of study? What are the main theories underlying empirical investigations? Finally, what are the main gaps in the existing literature, and what paths should we follow for future research?

Click here to read the full article.