Fixing medicine’s gender gap
Photo Credit: vectorfusionart - stock.adobe.co
Article Summary
-
Historical bias in medical research: The article highlights how medical research has historically focused on males, leading to a significant gap in understanding women’s health. This male-centric approach has resulted in women being more likely to experience delayed diagnoses, misdiagnoses and adverse drug reactions.
-
Impact of sex and gender differences: It discusses how sex and gender differences affect health outcomes, emphasising the need for medical research to consider these differences. The article points out that conditions like heart attacks and chronic pain manifest differently in women, necessitating tailored medical approaches.
-
Efforts to address the gap: The article details initiatives aimed at integrating sex and gender analysis into medical research. It mentions policies and frameworks being implemented by various organisations to ensure that research includes both male and female subjects and considers sex-specific data.
-
Future directions and challenges: The article concludes by discussing the ongoing challenges and the importance of continuing efforts to close the gender gap in medical research. It underscores the benefits of inclusive research for improving healthcare outcomes for everyone, not just women.
Sex and gender affect all aspects of our health and wellbeing, from the risk of developing different conditions through to the way that those conditions present and how we may respond to different treatments. But historically, sex and gender have been ignored when it comes to medical research. From basic and preclinical research in cells, tissues and animals through to human clinical trials males have served as the research subject default for centuries, and it has been assumed that evidence from these male studies is equally applicable to females.
‘This would not be a big issue at all if it was the case that males and females are identical, aside from reproduction, and that we can take what we learn from males and apply it to females,’ says Bronwyn Graham, director of the Centre for Sex and Gender Equity in Health and Medicine at the George Institute for Global Health in Australia. ‘But of course, that’s not actually the case.’
And when studies have included both males and females, typically the results are not presented in a way that is disaggregated according to sex or gender where relevant. ‘What this means is that when there are sex differences, [they] aren’t being detected,’ adds Graham, who is also a clinical psychologist at the University of South Wales. ‘So when we are using that research to develop “evidence-based interventions”, that’s really more evidence-based for males than it is for females.’
This data gap in medical research is having real-life disadvantages for 51% of the population; women are more likely to wait longer for a diagnosis, be misdiagnosed or experience an adverse drug reaction. But making medical research more inclusive of sex and gender will not just help those who are currently underrepresented, it will drastically improve health outcomes for everyone.
The root of the problem
From the very earliest days of medicine when Greek philosopher Aristotle characterised females as ‘mutilated males’, it has been assumed that apart from size, weight and reproductive organs, males and females are the same. The issue has been perpetuated by the fact that throughout history the fields of science and medicine have largely been dominated by men.
Understanding of male and female bodies, and how they differ, has thankfully advanced, but until relatively recently the male medical standard has perpetuated. Kate Womersley, an NHS doctor and academic specialising in psychiatry, recalls the ‘blind spots’ she encountered while studying medicine at the University of Cambridge between 2014 and 2018.
‘We did cadaveric dissection to learn anatomy, and we had a handbook that talked through all the major parts of the body … some of those were sex specific … but there was no discussion of breasts at all, as if they didn’t exist,’ she remembers. ‘That was a theme in my training – often you were taught about medicine as if the body was sex neutral.’